Paper 1096 23.08.2004
by Dr. Subhash Kapila
Introductory Observations: Talibanisque Pattern Violence Continues:
Bangladesh’s
political violence spear headed by Islamic fundamentalist organisations
wishing to impose a Taliban state in Bangladesh stands regularly
highlighted in this author’s papers for the last six months.
Bangladesh’s
Government’s marked inactivity in controlling or restraining this
spiraling trend of political violence against the more democratic
elements of Bangladesh’s polity also stands noted earlier.
Two major developments in the last fortnight which reinforce the above trend, and are singularly disturbing are:
- Assassination attempts on Opposition and Awami Party leader Sheikh Hasina at a public rally in Dhaka in August 21, 2004.
- Islamic fundamentalists witch-hunt of Ahmediyas and desecration of Ahmediya mosques.
The
Bangladesh Government except for a terse disapproval of such incidents
by the President and Prime Minister has not come out with any forceful
condemnation of these two developments leaving question marks on
the Prime Minister Begum Khalida Zia’s intentions or her likely
political captivity in the hands of Islamic fundamentalists.
Bangladesh
seems to be sitting on a volcano whose political explosion could have
serious implications for India and the region and so also for the United
States besides violent upheaval in Bangladesh itself. But first a brief
coverage on the two developments listed above.
Assassination Bid Against Awami Party Leader, Begum Sheikh Hasina Wajed.
A
string of 13 grenade explosions took place at an Awami League political
rally being addressed in Dhaka on August 21, 2004 by Sheikh
Hasina. This political rally was being held to protest the Sylhet,
bombings, political killings and fundamentalist terrorism, that has
plagued Bangladesh, in recent times.
Fortunately,
Sheikh Hasina escaped unhurt, but many in the protective ring around
her were killed or wounded. The tally is of 18 dead so far and 300
injured including top leaders of the Awami League.
Bangladesh
virtually stands paralysed thereafter by nationwide strikes in the
first 24 hours, followed by mass protest prayers on August 22 to be
followed by nation wide strikes on August 24-25. All of these have the
potential for generating violent clashes in view of the highly
politically emotive environment generated by this assassination bid.
Tensions
are high in Dhaka and there have been clashes across the country
including burning of six bogies of a Chittagong-Dhaka train. It may be
recalled from one of my papers in July 2004, that Sheikh Hasina had
received death threats both in Dhaka and while she was in Istanbul for a
conference. She had warned the Government that it would be held
responsible for her death. The Bangladesh Government seems not to have
paid much heed to her warning.
Major Deductions From the Assassination Attempt
The major deductions that emerge are as under:
- Begum
Zia’s Government is not serious in tackling the spiraling Talibanisque
type of political violence, including assassination of Opposition
leaders.
- Begum Zia is a political
captive in the hands of her Islamic fundamentalist coalition parties who
would like Sheikh Hasina’s exit from the political scene.
- The
pattern of grenade throwing at a rally of 25,000 Awami League
supporters in front of their Central Office in Dhaka and the firing of
weapons on Sheikh Hasina’s car in which she was being whisked away
clearly indicates that the main target of this violence was the
assassination of Sheikh Hasiana.
- With
just about two years left for the next general elections, the
Bangladesh Govt. perceives that Sheikh Hasina may be gaining lost
political ground by forging some coalition with a dozen odd parties to
prevent the return of the Islamic fundamentalist coalition led by Begum
Zia. Assassination attempts, violent disruptions of political rallies
and death threats may be a means of coercing would-be political
coalition partners of Sheikh Hasina's Awami League, not to align with
the Awami League.
Religious Persecution of the Ahmediya Sect of Bangladesh Muslims:
Bangladesh’s
Islamic fundamentalists in a replay of Pakistan’s persecution of the
Ahmediya sect of Muslims and the Taliban’s aggression on non-Sunni
Muslim sects have launched a strong campaign against Bangladeshi
Ahmediyas. Ahmediya mosques are being desecrated and worship being
prevented.
In this connection, the following needs to be noted:
- Chairman
of Islamic Okiyo Jote (Islami fundamentalist party) a member of the
ruling alliance has gone to the extent of issuing an ultimatum in public
that Ahmediyas should be declared non-Muslims, if the Begum Zia
government wishes to stay in power.
- “Khatime
Nabuwat Andolan Parishad, (Bangladesh)" claiming support of ruling
alliance partner Jamaat e Islami (Islamic fundamentalist party) stated
on August 15, 2004, that it will keep on laying a siege to all Ahmediya
mosques in the country till such time the Ahmediyas identify their place
of worship as mosques.
Bangladesh Seems to be Sitting on a Political Volcano:
It
would not be far from the truth to say that Bangladesh is presently
sitting on a political volcano which could explode anytime.
The following factors need to be considered in this context:
- Law and order has totally disintegrated. The Administration seems to be in grip of the fear of the Islamic Jehadis.
- Islamic
fundamentalist parties and Islamic militant outfits are having a free
run in Bangladesh in pursuance of their declared objective to make
Bangladesh a Taliban state.
- Assassination
bids against opposition political leaders, intelligentsia and media
journalists seems to be becoming an everyday occurrence.
- Hindus and non-Sunni sects of Muslims are being persecuted by Bangladesh’s Islamic fundamentalist organizations.
- Islamic
fundamentalist leaders openly mock the judicial processes and the
police is hampered by the ruling party alliances Islamic leaders
reducing them to a helpless spectator.
In
such a strife torn and oppressive political situation, most of the
Bangladesh masses cannot be expected to remain as mute spectators. The
masses cannot be expected to be in state of “ frozen paralysis” due to
the terrorization by Islamic fundamentalists. Sharp reactions from the
“silent majority” in terms of counter-violence cannot be ruled out.
And, when that happens Bangladesh will explode in a cycle of violence and counter- violence.
The
Bangladesh media has been valiantly raising its voice against this
trend of assassinations and mindless political violence. One editorial
on August 22, 2004 makes the following observations:
- Pattern
of the assassination attack on Sheikh Hasina points out a very well
organized, well planned and professionally executed operation.
- “ We have been alerting the Government, ad nauseun to get at the roots of the bomb blasts that have occurred in the country.”
- “We had also cautioned the authorities of the consequences of letting the incidents go untracked and unsolved.”
The pointers are unambiguous and the portents are dangerous for Bangladesh.
Bangladesh Portents Have Serious Implications:
India
would be the most seriously impacted by a explosion of political
violence in Bangladesh. Spillovers of any violent uprisings in
Bangladesh lead to an influx of Bangladesh refugees on a mass scale and
raising of both political and economic costs. Also such a situation,
(reminiscent of 1971) would not permit India to remain as a passive and
impotent observer.
Regionally,
political violence and turbulence also has an impact on Myanmar, Bhutan
and Nepal. South Asian regional security on the whole gets affected.
The United States in such an event, would have a myriad of problems of which the two major ones can be recounted:
- United
States will not have one “failed state” (in a high state of Islamic
fundamentalisation and Talibanisque mould) but two “failed states” in
South Asia, to cater for politically and militarily, namely Pakistan and
Bangladesh. Both have matching symptoms now.
- A
Talibanised Bangladesh would impinge heavily on US national security
interests in South East Asia, ranging from Al Qaedism to security of
strategic choke points.
Concluding Observations:
Bangladesh
seems to be currently sitting on a political volcano. The nascent
democracy in Bangladesh is under Islamic fundamentalist attack. The
Bangladesh Government led by Begum Zia, has not demonstrated in the last
six months, any noticeable intents of seriousness, to arrest the
downslide. The downslide into political violence, assassinations and
bombings is the handiwork of Islamic fundamentalist organisations
determined to make Bangladesh into a Taliban state. The Prime Minister
Begum Zia is unable to act against these elements as their sponsors form
part of the Government. Therefore, the Prime Minister is a political
captive in their hands.
Failed
states in any part of the world are a security threat to their neighbors
to the region and also to the global unipolar power. The United States
perceives it so and this is reflected in its national security
documents.
The sponsors of
Bangladesh’s attempted Talibanisation are United States allies and
depend heavily on American support systems. To prevent a volcanic
explosion in Bangladesh, the United Sates needs to restrain its
protégés. Its reluctance in the past led to the emergence of Al Qaedists
and the senseless bombings of 9/11.
The
United States and India, chiefly, need to put their heads together to
prevent the emergence of another security headache in South Asia,
impinging on their national security interests and also their mutual
convergences in this field.
(The
author is an International Relations and Strategic Affairs analyst. He
is the Consultant, Strategic Affairs with South Asia Analysis Group.
Email drsubhashkapila @yahoo.com)
http://www.southasiaanalysis.org/paper1096